Let’s jump in and look at the options!
1. Decoded leather magnetic pencil sleeve – Editor’s choice
Compatible with – 1st and 2nd generation Apple Pencil
Of course, the best Apple Pencil case has to be a product designed and offered by Apple. The Decoded leather magnetic sleeve is perfect for your Apple Pencil, whether you’re using the first-generation Pencil or the second. It’s made of premium full-grain aniline leather, with a magnet closure that you can use to fit the first-generation or second-generation Apple Pencil. Moreover, it can integrate into your iPad’s smart cover to form the perfect digital notebook. Additionally, it has a sophisticated design that merges seamlessly into professional work environments. The only major con of this sleeve is that it’s quite expensive compared to third-party sleeves. Check out on: Apple
Compatible with both generations of Apple PencilSeamlessly integrates to the iPad’s Smart CoverGreat build quality
Expensive
2. ESR pencil holder – Elegant design
Compatible with – 1st and 2nd Generation Apple Pencils
The ESR Pencil Holder is one of the best cases for Apple Pencils, with a sleek and minimalist look that radiates efficiency. The pencil holder is compatible with both generations of the Apple Pencil, making it a lasting and versatile option. The adhesive backing provided with the sleeve keeps it in place, regardless of how rough you use it. Moreover, the sleeve’s elasticity ensures that your Apple Pencil is held securely and doesn’t fall out even if you’ve turned it upside down. Lastly, you can choose where you want to stick the sleeve, ensuring it’s always available for use. While the sleeve looks great, multiple users have reported that the build quality could’ve been better.
Sleek and minimal designExcellent fitCan be placed on any side of the iPad cover
Subpar build quality
3. Belkin Apple Pencil case – Premium option
Compatible with – 1st and 2nd generation Apple Pencil
Belkin has always offered excellent products in every category for Apple’s devices. This Apple Pencil case is no different, and it provides the same top-notch quality assurance synonymous with Belkin. This case comes with storage compartments for the Lightning adapter, a pencil cap, and a pencil tip. The case also doubles as a holder for easy use. Finally, the case is durable, with a polycarbonate exterior and a fabric lining for a good in-hand feel. Unfortunately, it would’ve been better if they had added a hinge for the protective case at this price point. This would make it easier to operate.
Can be used as both a case and holderQuite durableComfortable to use
A hinge would’ve made the case easier to use
4. elago classic pencil case – Designed in-house
Compatible with – 2nd generation Apple Pencil
If you want a case for your Apple Pencil that stands out, this offering from elago is a great option. It’s designed in-house instead of being mass-produced like the other cases in this price segment. This ensures that you’re getting a quality product. Moreover, the case’s design gives you a nostalgic feel, taking the pencil name pretty seriously and providing an old-school pencil design. It’s made of premium silicone materials to ensure durability as well. However, you must remember that this case is only compatible with the second-generation Apple Pencil. The edges of the case are sharp, especially around the area used for gripping the pencil. This isn’t ideal for anyone with soft hands.
Designed in-house for excellent qualityThe aesthetics provide an old-school nostalgic feelPremium materials
Sharp edges lead to bad ergonomics
5. AhaStyle Ultra Thin Case – Value for money
Compatible with – 2nd Generation Apple Pencil
This AhaStyle Ultra Thin Case is perfect for users who prefer efficient buys over luxurious ones. The pack comes with two cases, leaving you with an extra case that you can give to a friend or family. In any case, you’re always going to have an extra case if you need it. The case only fits the second-generation Apple Pencil and is quite thin at 0.35mm. Considering how thin the case is, it doesn’t impede magnetic charging either. The case’s thinness also lends it a lightweight factor that feels good ergonomically. It can be difficult to install, though. I recommend that you read the instructions thoroughly before initiating the installation process.
Two cases for the price of oneUltra-thin caseLightweight Ergonomic
Challenging to install
6. KELIFANG Silicone Case Sleeve – Convenient to use
Compatible with – 2nd Generation Apple Pencil
Plenty of Apple Pencil cases in the market provide extra features but skimp on the convenience factor. After all, no matter how many features you add to the sleeve or case, if it isn’t easy to use, it won’t fit the bill. The sleeve is made using high-quality silicone materials that are eco-friendly as well. It’s only compatible with second-generation Apple Pencils, however. Regardless, it’s still easy to install, and since it’s got multiple color options, you can easily switch between the variants considering the ease of installation. Lastly, since the sleeve is ultra-thin, it doesn’t affect the magnetic charging either. Some users have reported that the case is quite big. So, it might not fit your iPad cover with a built-in pencil case.
Good build qualityEasy to install and usePlenty of color optionsUltra-thin design for easy charging
Might not fit your iPad cover if it comes with a built-in pencil case
7. Delidigi pencil case – For an on-hand experience
Compatible with – 2nd generation Apple Pencil
This case is for the second generation of Apple Pencils. It comes with a silicone material that’s soft on the hands and makes the case easier to grip. Since the case is thin, it doesn’t interfere with the magnetic process and can easily fit on the side of your iPad. This allows you to keep the Apple Pencil handy, being available for use at all times. It also comes in various color options, based on your preference. However, some users have reported that it can cause issues when charging the Apple Pencil. You’ll have to remove the cover to ensure that it is charging.
Decent build qualityFits the iPad’s side easilyMany color options
Can impede charging
8. ProCase pencil holder – Holder + sticker
Compatible with – 1st and 2nd generation Apple Pencil
This Apple Pencil case doubles as a sticker and holder at the front or back of your iPad cover. Moreover, it’s compatible with both generations of Apple Pencils. Further, the case is made of premium PU leather, making it resistant to most bumps and scratches. Moreover, the sleeve is elastic, adding protection and a secure grip to ensure that your Apple Pencil does not fall out unexpectedly. Unfortunately, a few users have stated that they’ve received defective products. Ensure that your product matches the description and has a good build quality if you purchase it.
Doubles as a sticker and holderGood build qualitySecure
Possibility of receiving a defective product
9. AGPTEK Case Holder – Versatile
Compatible with – 2nd generation Apple Pencil
If you’re looking for an Apple Pencil case holder providing multiple functions, check this product from AGPTEK. It features a simple case design that provides the compartments and spaces the pencil needs. The product uses good quality materials, making it resistant to dust or scratches. Additionally, it also protects your accessories from coming into contact with water or other liquids. The case also features a mesh pocket inside for storing other peripherals. Overall, this is a great item if you’re looking for an all-in-one solution. It’s perfect for a second-generation Apple Pencil. However, the versatility comes at a cost. It makes the case pretty bulky.
Decent buildVersatile with many compartments
Can be bulky and difficult to carry around
10. Fintie Pencil Holder – Budget pick
Compatible with – 1st and 2nd generation Apple Pencil
If you need an Apple Pencil case or Pencil holder desperately and are on a shoestring budget, go for the Fintie pencil holder with your eyes closed. This holder is perfect for either generation of Apple Pencils, and it’s made of vegan leather! Additionally, the case comes with an adapter pocket, ensuring a safe, secure, and handy place to keep your adapter. Overall, it gives your Apple Pencil a classic look and a lightweight feel. There is an issue with the design, however. It can be annoying to use the leather flap for securing the Apple Pencil each time. A smaller, magnetic clasp would’ve done a better job.
Aggressive pricingComes with a pocket for the adapterMade of vegan leather
Using the leather flap to secure the pencil can be annoying
The takeaway These were my picks for the best Apple Pencil cases, covers, and sleeves. Considering how important the Apple Pencil can be for certain situations, it only makes sense to go the extra mile and purchase a protective cover. Have you tried any of these products before? If so, how has your experience been? Let me know in the comments below! Read more:
Apple Pencil tip replacement: When and how to do itHow to pair, unpair, and charge Apple Pencil with iPadHow to find a lost Apple Pencil (1st & 2nd generation)iPad apps to use Apple Pencil (Drawing + Note-taking + Annotation)
